By Graham Sterling, PhD, licensed clinical psychologist and former U.S. Navy psychologist
BLUF
He still startles when someone raises their voice. She still drives the long way home so she doesn't have to pass one particular street. When I ask about it, they both tell me the same thing. Other people had it worse. That one sentence keeps a lot of people out of treatment, and a 2025 study suggests it shouldn't. In a randomized trial, EMDR reduced trauma symptoms in people who didn't meet the full criteria for PTSD. It also helped with memories that fall outside the official definition of trauma (Hafkemeijer et al., 2025). You don't need the diagnosis to deserve the help.
Why people rule themselves out
PTSD has a formal definition. The event has to involve death, threatened death, serious injury, or sexual violence. Clinicians call that Criterion A. A lot of what brings people into my office doesn't fit it. A childhood spent managing a parent's moods. Years of being belittled by someone whose opinion ran the house. A medical scare that turned out fine. None of that makes the list, so people decide it shouldn't still be bothering them.
It still is, though, and that mismatch turns into its own problem. People feel weak for reacting to something they've already decided was minor.
What the study found
Hafkemeijer and colleagues (2025) studied 159 adults with a personality disorder. Some met the full criteria for PTSD and some didn't. Each person was randomly assigned to EMDR or to a waitlist. The EMDR group did better either way. For people without a PTSD diagnosis, the improvement was moderate to large right after treatment, and it got bigger by follow-up. EMDR also reduced symptoms tied to memories that didn't meet Criterion A. Among the people who did have PTSD, about two thirds no longer met the diagnosis after treatment. By follow-up that number was 73 percent.
It's one trial in one group of patients, so I don't want to oversell it. Still, it tested the exact belief people walk in with, and that belief didn't hold up.
Where we actually start
When you come in, we don't start by ranking what happened to you. We start with what the memory is still doing. Maybe a raised voice still shuts you down. Maybe one street still changes your route home. Maybe you still brace for criticism that never comes. That's what we work on. Whether it was "bad enough" matters a lot less than whether it's still running part of your life.
If it is, it's worth treating. If you've been talking yourself out of getting help, you can stop. Reach out, and we'll start with whatever is still getting in your way.
Key Takeaways
Many people rule out their own trauma because it doesn't meet the formal definition, or because someone else had it worse.
In a trial of 159 adults, EMDR reduced trauma symptoms whether or not people met the full criteria for PTSD (Hafkemeijer et al., 2025).
EMDR also helped with memories that fall outside Criterion A.
About two thirds of people with PTSD no longer met the diagnosis after treatment, and the gains held at follow-up.
The question that matters is whether the memory is still running part of your life.
Graham Sterling, PhD, is the founder of The Sterling Practice. He offers individual therapy and adjunctive EMDR by secure telehealth across Massachusetts and Maine, working mostly with veterans, first responders, and other adults dealing with trauma, PTSD, and burnout. Book at tspractice.com or call (617) 299-1296.
References
Hafkemeijer, L., Hofman, S., de Jongh, A., de Roos, D., van Velzen, M., Starrenburg, A., & Slotema, K. (2025). The effectiveness of EMDR therapy on PTSD symptoms and diagnostic status in patients with a personality disorder: A randomized controlled trial. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 94(6), 453-465. https://doi.org/10.1159/000547622